Как работают президентские мемуары

Президентские мемуары, как правило, вызывают много шума. В последние годы и президент Билл Клинтон, и президент Джордж Буш опубликовали мемуары, но из всех предыдущих президентов США на удивление небольшое число действительно написали мемуары. Учитывая вездесущие политические публикации нашего времени, трудно представить, чтобы какой-либо президент действительно упустил возможность рассказать свою историю своими словами, но многие так и сделали.

Те немногие, кто решил записать историю со своей уникальной точки зрения, безусловно, воспользовались возможностью высказать свое мнение. В предисловии к своим двухтомным мемуарам объемом более 1000 страниц Гарри С. Трумэн пишет:

В этой статье мы рассмотрим, что такое президентские мемуары и кто потратил время на их написание. Мы также рассмотрим другие мемуары, связанные с президентством, в том числе мемуары, написанные кандидатами в президенты и первыми леди. Мемуары одной бывшей первой леди, «Живая история» Хиллари Родэм Клинтон, побили рекорды продаж.

1. Что такое президентские мемуары?
2. Форматы президентских мемуаров
3. Многотомники
4. Отдельные тома и сокращенные тексты
5. Вспомогательный отзыв
6. Автобиографический рассказ
7. "Моя жизнь"
8. Первые леди
9. Истинная откровенность
10. Разрешение споров

Для многих из нас не существует разницы между автобиографией и мемуарами. Но, как согласится большинство издателей, разница есть, хотя и незначительная. Основы те же: и автобиография, и мемуары пишутся о человеке им самим (иногда с помощью других).

Итак, что изменилось? Это настоящий контент. Вообще говоря, автобиография является всеобъемлющей, охватывающей всю жизнь субъекта от рождения до момента написания. Сюжетная линия, чаще всего, разворачивается линейно и беспристрастно, охватывая по пути большинство основных событий. Реже история извивается взад и вперед во времени, затрагивая мешанину тем, которые субъект считает нужным обсудить.

Мемуары, однако, обычно сосредоточены на определенной части жизни человека или определенной теме . В некоторых случаях события могут охватывать всю жизнь субъекта, но они передаются в связи с каким-то фокусом . Таким образом, президентские мемуары представляют собой либо снимок, либо полное представление о жизни президента, связанной с его президентством.

Теперь давайте поближе познакомимся с президентскими публикациями.

Формат, в котором человек решает представить свои мемуары, зависит от личного выбора, а иногда и от практичности. Несколько президентов (и их первые леди) вели ежедневные дневники до и во время своего пребывания в должности — отличный ресурс для написания мемуаров, полностью посвященных этому президентству. Но не все потеряно для тех, кто не смог провести ежедневную сидячую встречу со своим дневником. Такие записи, как календари, расписания, письменная корреспонденция в виде писем, а теперь и электронной почты , речи, отчеты и другие материалы могут использоваться для оживления памяти и поддержки или уточнения сюжетной линии.

Как вы узнали из предыдущего раздела, мемуары президента могут быть отформатированы одним из двух способов:

Любой из этих форматов может производить сотни и сотни страниц текста. Сначала легко подумать, что вариант капсулы времени будет короче, чем тип автобиографии. Однако, возможно, из-за требуемого уровня фокусировки в некоторых случаях этот формат создает даже больше текста.

Чтобы проиллюстрировать это положение и рассмотреть стиль, содержание и цель президентских мемуаров, рассмотрим несколько примеров.

Поскольку мемуары написали очень немногие, интересно, что тридцать третий, тридцать четвертый и тридцать шестой президенты Соединенных Штатов (Трумэн, Эйзенхауэр и Джонсон) выбрали именно это. Трумэн, Эйзенхауэр и Джонсон выбрали один и тот же формат — написание мемуаров, конкретно посвященных периоду их президентства. (Можно только гадать, что сделал бы тридцать пятый президент Джон Фицджеральд Кеннеди, если бы ему представилась такая возможность.)

В двухтомник Трумэна входят:

В предисловии к обеим книгам (оно идентично) Трумэн фактически комментирует недостаток президентских мемуаров:

По иронии судьбы бывший президент Герберт Гувер сделал подобное наблюдение в предисловии к своим мемуарам. Могло ли случиться так, что Трумэн прочитал мемуары Гувера до того, как написал свои собственные? Вполне возможно: несколько президентов ссылались на то, что они читали работы своих предшественников, прежде чем взяться за перо, — не считая Билла Клинтона. Фактически, сообщалось, что до написания своих мемуаров «Моя жизнь» Клинтон прочитал все мемуары бывших президентов.

Человек с серебряным долларом

Эйзенхауэр также представил свои мемуары в двухтомнике:

Both Truman's and Eisenhower's memoirs are very detailed. Stylistically though, Eisenhower's memoir is a bit different: With a slight novel-like feel, the volumes are broken down into broad sections that he calls "books," each with several chapters. Each book begins with two or three quotes, usually some text from a speech given by Eisenhower himself and then a quote or two from another famous politician or former president.

...if anything here -- the story of a lesson learned, a principle proved, or an old truth emphasized -- should be found of value by those who in years to come will bear responsibilities in the federal government, all of us who served this nation in my administration will be deeply rewarded.

Dwight D. Eisenhower

Lyndon B. Johnson takes a more abbreviated tack on retelling the tale of his term in office. His memoir, "The Vantage Point: Perspectives of the Presidency, 1963-1969," fills only one volume. Johnson is very straightforward about the nature of his memoir and why and how he formats it the way he does. He informs the reader that this is not a "definitive history of his Presidency" -- that it is merely a review of his term from his own vantage point:

Many presidents acknowledge the help of others in creating their memoirs, but very few share author credit with another writer. In "A World Transformed," former President George Bush goes against convention in two ways. Not only does he share top billing with former National Security Advisor Brent Scowcroft, but together the two discuss only a portion of Bush's presidency -- limiting their coverage to 1989 through 1991.

While Bush didn't create a complete memoir of his presidency, the work "All the Best, George Bush: My Life in Letters and Other Writings" -- composed primarily of excerpts from his diaries, letters and other correspondence -- stands in well for a memoir of the autobiographical vein. Let's take a look at some other presidential writings of this sort.

Although he is not often thought of as a great president, Ulysses S. Grant is noted for the manner in which he relayed the story of his early life and his participation in the Civil War. The text begins with a rather brief discussion of his birth, childhood and early schooling. From there, he takes the reader from West Point to the Mexican War to life in California to Shiloh to the campaign against and the eventual surrender of Vicksburg. In writing his memoir, Grant set a good standard of relying heavily on papers, correspondence and official reports he had written during the war, along with the assistance of several researchers. To date, Grant's is arguably the most well-known, well-read and well-respected of the presidential memoirs. (Technically, it falls just short of being a full-blown presidential memoir, in that Grant passed away prior to writing about his term in office.) Most people agree that the story surrounding the writing of Grant's memoir is almost as good a tale as the memoir itself.

In his own words, on the topic of writing a memoir, Grant was "determined never to do so." But, because a failed business venture left Grant in dire financial straights, he was forced to reconsider. "The Century," a publication that was presenting a series on the Civil War, asked Grant to write a few articles (for which he would be paid) about the various battles in which he participated. The article request quickly turned into an offer of a book deal. One of Grant's friends, who was a writer himself, heard about the book deal and informed Grant that the proposed financial arrangement wasn't what it could be. The author and friend -- a man named Samuel Clemens (we know him best as Mark Twain) -- had recently started his own publishing house with his nephew, Charles L. Webster. Able to make a better offer, Webster and Clemens won Grant away from "The Century." In the end, over 300,000 copies of Grant's memoir were sold, providing Grant's family with the financial security he was hoping for and then some. Reportedly, Grant's widow was paid a record sum in royalties for that time, eventually receiving in excess of $400,000.

On Our Merry Way

Instead of waiting to write their post-presidency memoir, many presidential hopefuls are getting a head-start on their political publishing. Here are just a few politicians who have lined the campaign trail with a literary work:

• John Kerry - "A Call to Service: My Vision for a Better America"
• John Edwards - "Four Trials" (with John Auchard)
• George W. Bush - "A Charge to Keep: My Journey to the White House"
• Bill Clinton - "Between Hope and History: Meeting America's Challenges for the 21st Century"
• Al Gore - "Earth in the Balance: Ecology and the Human Spirit"
• Joseph & Haddasah Lieberman - "An Amazing Adventure: Joe and Hadassah's Personal Notes on the 2000 Campaign"

Somewhat shorter than most other presidential memoirs, "The Autobiography of Calvin Coolidge" is very much like its title would suggest -- a standard autobiography. The pages of his memoir move solidly from his childhood to his education and through his political career. In reading through his as well as several other presidential memoirs, it's interesting to see that many former presidents share a similar sentiment -- that it is very difficult to describe what being president is like:

From a historical perspective, from memoir to memoir there are bits of commentary along the way that illustrate the changing times not only within the presidential office, but also in the surrounding world. On train travel, Coolidge had this to say:

Obviously, things have come a long way since then. One can only wonder what Coolidge would think of Air Force One .

Some other former presidents who decided to present their memoir in an autobiographical format are:

Although Clinton chose an autobiographical style pioneered by previous presidents, the media frenzy surrounding the release of Clinton's memoir, "My Life," may establish the work as groundbreaking through the mere virtue of press coverage. Let's take a closer look.

Anyone who believes that a Presidential campaign includes a luxurious life for the candidate needs further instruction.

Herbert Hoover

Even before the writing began, former President Bill Clinton's memoir was different from those of previous presidents -- no other presidential memoir has garnered a $10 million advance. For comparison, President George W. Bush was reportedly paid $7 million total for his 2010 memoir "Decision Points" [source: Sheridan]. The up-front money, along with a record-breaking first printing of 1.5 million copies, is proof-positive that publisher Alfred A. Knopf believed Clinton's story -- all 957 pages of it -- was going to be a huge success.

Shortly before its release, "My Life" was ranked No. 1 in Amazon.com's sales rankings, an achievement Bush's "Decision Points" repeated six years later. "My Life" enjoyed an ongoing spot in the top-10 at Amazon and sold more than 2 million copies. Clinton's first main appearance on a tour to support the book -- at BookExpo America -- filled the 2,700-person convention room beyond capacity. The tour was extensive, with book signings and talks at book stores across the country, along with a host of radio and television talk show appearances. He also spoke with Dan Rather on CBS's news show, "60 Minutes" and on the other major networks, including ABC's Oprah Winfrey show.

Bill Clinton isn't the only successful author in the Clinton family -- former first lady Hillary Clinton has seen great success with her memoir, "Living History." In fact, first ladies generally see more success with their publishing than their spouses do. Let's take a closer look at this counterpart to the presidential memoir.

When I was a young man, getting out of law school, I said one of the goals I had in life was to write a great book. I have no earthly idea if it's a great book. But, it's a pretty good story.

Bill Clinton

The writings of first ladies generally draw more interest than that of the presidents themselves. Most of the more recent former first ladies have author credits to their names:

Several first ladies have expressed sadness, fear and even grief at their husband's election to the office of President. Although able to express happiness for her spouse and what his victory means to him and even to the country, many a first lady has known the price that her husband's success would exact on her own life.

Eleanor Roosevelt was a prolific writer -- and not just by first lady standards. There are more than 15 books to her credit. During her husband's presidency, Mrs. Roosevelt even had a weekly newspaper column. Initially, she published a three-volume autobiography. It is the second volume of this work, "This I Remember," that can be considered a true first-lady memoir. It is obvious that the sole purpose behind the writing of this work is her husband:

She later combined the three volumes -- "This Is My Story," "This I Remember" and "On My Own" -- into one work that she shortened and updated. Mrs. Roosevelt also added entirely new material in a final section entitled "The Search for Understanding."

I was happy for my husband ... But for myself I was deeply troubled. As I saw it, this meant the end of any personal life of my own ... I had seen what it meant to be the wife of a president, and I cannot say that I was pleased at the prospect.

Eleanor Roosevelt

Betty Ford sums up her first lady experience with great honesty when she writes:

Mrs. Ford's memoir spans the years of her life leading right up to the writing of her book. She discusses everything from her childhood to her first marriage (which ended at age 29) to her marriage with President Gerald Ford. Mrs. Ford also writes about her children, life as a first lady and her struggle with breast cancer . She's remarkably candid in her discussion, including this comment on how terrified she was to be interviewed by Barbara Walters:

Her candor didn't stop there -- she even addresses the issue of her addiction to alcohol and prescription drugs. At the beginning of the final chapter, with grace and a touch of humor, Mrs. Ford talks about how, just when she thought she had finished writing, she realized she had one more chapter to write -- one more story to tell.

All in the Family

Sometimes, more than just the first ladies of the White House decide to divulge the depths of their diaries. Three of former President Ronald Reagan's children each published a memoir:

• Patty Davis - "The Way I See It: An Autobiography"
• Michael Reagan - "On the Outside Looking in" (with Joe Hyams)
• Maureen Reagan - "First Father, First Daughter: A Memoir by Maureen Reagan"

In writing her memoirs, Mrs. Ronald Reagan utilized the diary she kept while residing in the White House. The story opens on March 30, 1981, the day her husband -- President Ronald Reagan -- was shot. From there it meanders back and forth through time, covering an array of subjects, including her much criticized dependence on astrology and her relationship with San Francisco astrologer Joan Quigley:

Mrs. Reagan touches on a host of other topics, including:

A Living HERstory

Shortly after its release, Hillary Clinton's memoir, "Living History," was making and breaking all sorts of publishing records. The book's sales were so high within the first week alone that the publisher managed to earn back the almost $3 million advance (and then some) it had paid Clinton.

There were several things driving the first round of sales of "Living History" -- specifically, certain elements of controversy surrounding the Clintons' time in the White House and talk about a possible run for the presidency by the former first lady. With her husband's memoir hitting the shelves, it's highly likely that her book will enjoy a another surge of popularity.

For more information on presidential memoirs and related topics, check out the links on the following page.

Мои восемь лет в Белом доме стали испытанием для моей веры и политических убеждений, моего брака и Конституции нашей страны. Я стала громоотводом для политических и идеологических сражений за будущее Америки и магнитом для чувств, хороших и плохих, о женском выборе и роли. Эта книга — история о том, как я пережила эти восемь лет в качестве первой леди и жены президента.

Хиллари Родэм Клинтон

Статьи по Теме

Больше отличных ссылок

Список используемой литературы

Вот некоторые источники, которые мы нашли полезными при исследовании этой статьи:

Веб-страница

Книги